{{status_msg}}

Home Prices Are Softening. What Buyers Can Negotiate Now

Posted:

November 17th

  • Share on Facebook

For over three years, the average home in the United States consistently fetched a price higher than the previous year's. However, that trend has now shifted. Recent data from October reveals that the median selling price of homes has dipped below what it was a year prior, marking the first annual decline since spring 2023. Concurrently, the housing inventory has reached its peak since early 2020, with pending sales dropping to the lowest level observed in over a decade, excluding early-pandemic times, and around 20% of all listings have experienced price reductions.

There's a twist to the situation: borrowing costs have surged. The typical 30-year fixed mortgage rate has recently risen back to the mid-7% range after a fleeting phase of improvement. Consequently, while buyers are gaining some negotiating power, the ongoing monthly payments may still stretch many budgets.

This unique scenario creates an opportunity. With a decline in offers and homes lingering longer on the market, sellers are likely to be more flexible regarding pricing and terms. If you're in the market for a home this winter, consider these areas that may be negotiable, and collaborate with your agent and lender on the best approach.

Understanding the Implications of a Small Price Drop

The national decrease of less than half a percent isn't indicative of a market collapse, nor does it suggest that prices are declining uniformly across the country. While some affluent coastal regions with limited inventory continue to see significant price increases, several major metropolitan areas in the South and West have witnessed price drops of several percent compared to last year. Thus, your specific market conditions are far more relevant than national trends.

The national statistics indicate a change in market dynamics. When homes stay on the market longer and an abundance of listings competes for a limited pool of buyers, sellers are more inclined to negotiate. This openness can manifest in the sale price, but it often extends to the overall terms of the transaction as well.

Considering More Than Just the Price

Buyers often fixate on the purchase price alone. However, in a high-interest-rate environment, the total monthly payment and the cash required at closing may be of greater importance. A reduction of a few thousand dollars in price has only a minor impact on the overall loan amount. Conversely, those same funds allocated differently can provide a more significant benefit to your financial situation. Common topics for negotiation in a slower market include:

  • A purchase price lower than the listing amount
  • Credits from the seller toward closing costs
  • Completion of repairs before closing, or a credit in lieu of repairs
  • Seller-funded contributions to lower your mortgage rate
  • A closing schedule or moving timeline that aligns with your needs
  • Included items like appliances or window coverings

Your agent is well-acquainted with local seller responses and can assist you in determining which items to prioritize when making an offer. The aim is to request what will make the most significant impact on your situation rather than asking for everything available.

How Closing Cost Credits Can Alleviate Financial Strain

Closing costs typically account for a few percentage points of the loan amount, in addition to your down payment. For many first-time homebuyers, gathering enough cash can present the most significant hurdle. A seller credit can help cover a portion of these costs directly, allowing you to bring a lower amount to the closing table.

However, there are limits to seller contributions. Loan programs generally cap how much a seller can provide, often ranging from 3% to 9% of the sale price based on the loan type and the size of your down payment, with credits typically not exceeding the actual closing costs. It's crucial to consult with your lender early on to understand your specific loan parameters so that your requests in the offer adhere to the guidelines.

Understanding Rate Buydowns

With interest rates now over 7%, one beneficial offer from a seller could involve assistance with your mortgage rate. There are primarily two types of buydowns to consider.

A permanent buydown involves paying discount points at closing to secure a lower interest rate for the entire loan duration. Each point equates to 1% of the loan total, with the extent of rate reduction depending on the lender and current market conditions. If you plan to hold onto the loan for an extended period, this could be advantageous.

A temporary buydown, on the other hand, decreases your initial payments for the first couple of years. A common structure offers a rate two percentage points lower in the first year and one percentage point lower in the second year before returning to the full rate. For instance, on a $350,000 loan with an interest rate around 7.34%, your monthly payment would initially be about $2,409. With a temporary buydown, you'd pay approximately $1,952 in the first year and around $2,176 in the second year before adjusting to the full price. Arranging for this setup could cost just over $8,000 in this scenario, which some sellers might prefer over reducing the purchase price directly by a similar amount.

It's essential to recognize that a temporary buydown is not a permanent remedy. You must be confident in your ability to manage the full payment once the discount period concludes. While refinancing may be available if rates decrease, it is impossible to predict when or if that will occur.

The Importance of Home Inspections

In a heated market, many buyers opted to waive home inspections or limit their contingencies to enhance their competitiveness. In a slower market, however, buyers can afford to retain these crucial protections. A detailed home inspection provides insights into the home's condition, including the roof, HVAC systems, plumbing, electrical work, and foundation prior to making a commitment.

If issues are identified during the inspection, your agent can help determine whether to pursue repairs, request a price modification, or seek a credit. Opting for credits can be less complicated than asking the seller to manage repairs since you control how and when the work is completed, but the right decision depends on the nature of the problem and the requirements of your loan.

Preparation for Financing is Key

Having negotiating power is relatively unhelpful if your financing isn't secure. In instances where sellers compare offers, they often lean toward buyers who present the highest likelihood of a smooth closing. Before diving into serious home hunting, aim for full preapproval rather than a quick prequalification. Understand your maximum comfortable monthly payment, not just the upper limit of your loan amount, and solicit loan estimates from multiple lenders. Ensure that each lender is clear on handling seller credits or buydowns to avoid any surprises later on.

Questions to Consider with Your Agent

  • What is the typical time homes spend on the market in this area, and how often do prices get adjusted?
  • Would a price reduction, closing cost credit, or rate buydown offer the most benefit for my budget?
  • How do the condition and history of this specific home influence what I should request?
  • What contingencies should I include in my offer to secure my interests?

Conclusion

Even with a softer market, purchasing a home may not equate to bargains, particularly with mortgage interest rates on the rise again. However, it does present well-prepared buyers with the opportunity to negotiate more favorable terms that align with their financial circumstances. By securing robust financing, clarifying your priorities, and receiving solid guidance from your agent and lender, you can navigate negotiations to achieve better conditions than what buyers experienced just a year or two ago.

Rewritten using AI

Send Us a Message